Skip to content

The First Time I Was Appointed to Represent a Death Penalty Defendant

A story by attorney Kevin Holmes, shared with the Death Penalty Resource and Defense Center and originally published in their December 2014 Newsletter

“The first time I was appointed to represent a death penalty defendant was back in the early 1980’s. I hadn’t even been practicing law ten years yet. It was a double murder; one murder took place in Charleston County and the other in Berkeley County. The three defendants were from Sumter County. One of the defendants was cooperating and had agreed to testify against the other defendant and our client. It was alleged the defendants had traveled to Charleston to sell some guns they had stolen in a Richland County burglary of a gun store.

When they got to Charleston, the fence they were going to sell the guns to refused to deal with them. They were left stranded with no money so they robbed a gas station on the way out of town. They got about $20 and abducted the cashier, a Navy serviceman trying to earn some extra money to support his young family, who one defendant killed execution style on a dark road leaving Charleston County. Then, worrying the other two defendants would rat him out, he talked the other two into killing another late night convenience store clerk, by all accounts the nicest guy in town who not only ran the only all night convenience store, but worked at the local funeral home and knew everyone.

Co-counsel and I were appointed the week before Thanksgiving and went to trial the week following New Year’s Day. In those days, counsel got paid $2,500 to be split between them and I think you could get Court approval for up $2500 for investigation costs. To make matter worse, our client had been shot in the face with a shotgun and literally half his lower jaw was just about blown off. His jaw was wired shut and he had trouble communicating. The trial was held in Moncks Corner, a 45-minute drive away for a Charleston lawyer like me, adding additional hours to the 18-hour days we were spending trying to defend the case. The burden placed upon us was enormous to the point of being physically and mentally exhausting.

Our investigation was severely hampered because of the short time provided being over the holidays. I can still remember the opening line of my closing argument at the death penalty phase of the trial, “Even on my best day, I would be inadequate to find the words to argue for the life of another. This will not be my best day.”

I followed up by describing all the impossible hours that we had been putting in investigating, not only the crime, but the life circumstances of our client. Needless to say, it didn’t go well and the jury returned the death penalty. The best I can say is, I had some on the jury crying during my argument. I learned a lot about the death penalty but to this day I worry it was at the expense of my client, who deserved a lawyer with experience handling death penalty cases.

To think trying any other case can prepare a lawyer for the challenges of a death penalty trial where everything is stacked against you from the start, is wishful thinking. In the end I felt used as window dressing for the false notion the death penalty process is fair. I will always wonder if I had more experience, or time, or money it could have made a difference. Without the help of David Bruck and the Center, co-counsel and I wouldn’t have known where to begin the impossible task assigned to us.”

Personal Injury Lawyers Representing Charleston & nearby areas of South Carolina

RESULTS

WE HAVE RECOVERED OVER $500 MILLION FOR CLIENTS IN THE LAST 10 YEARS, INCLUDING:
$2,750,000 in a product defect case, scissor lift malfunction.

The First Time I Was Appointed to Represent a Death Penalty Defendant

A story by attorney Kevin Holmes, shared with the Death Penalty Resource and Defense Center and originally published in their December 2014 Newsletter

“The first time I was appointed to represent a death penalty defendant was back in the early 1980’s. I hadn’t even been practicing law ten years yet. It was a double murder; one murder took place in Charleston County and the other in Berkeley County. The three defendants were from Sumter County. One of the defendants was cooperating and had agreed to testify against the other defendant and our client. It was alleged the defendants had traveled to Charleston to sell some guns they had stolen in a Richland County burglary of a gun store.

When they got to Charleston, the fence they were going to sell the guns to refused to deal with them. They were left stranded with no money so they robbed a gas station on the way out of town. They got about $20 and abducted the cashier, a Navy serviceman trying to earn some extra money to support his young family, who one defendant killed execution style on a dark road leaving Charleston County. Then, worrying the other two defendants would rat him out, he talked the other two into killing another late night convenience store clerk, by all accounts the nicest guy in town who not only ran the only all night convenience store, but worked at the local funeral home and knew everyone.

Co-counsel and I were appointed the week before Thanksgiving and went to trial the week following New Year’s Day. In those days, counsel got paid $2,500 to be split between them and I think you could get Court approval for up $2500 for investigation costs. To make matter worse, our client had been shot in the face with a shotgun and literally half his lower jaw was just about blown off. His jaw was wired shut and he had trouble communicating. The trial was held in Moncks Corner, a 45-minute drive away for a Charleston lawyer like me, adding additional hours to the 18-hour days we were spending trying to defend the case. The burden placed upon us was enormous to the point of being physically and mentally exhausting.

Our investigation was severely hampered because of the short time provided being over the holidays. I can still remember the opening line of my closing argument at the death penalty phase of the trial, “Even on my best day, I would be inadequate to find the words to argue for the life of another. This will not be my best day.”

I followed up by describing all the impossible hours that we had been putting in investigating, not only the crime, but the life circumstances of our client. Needless to say, it didn’t go well and the jury returned the death penalty. The best I can say is, I had some on the jury crying during my argument. I learned a lot about the death penalty but to this day I worry it was at the expense of my client, who deserved a lawyer with experience handling death penalty cases.

To think trying any other case can prepare a lawyer for the challenges of a death penalty trial where everything is stacked against you from the start, is wishful thinking. In the end I felt used as window dressing for the false notion the death penalty process is fair. I will always wonder if I had more experience, or time, or money it could have made a difference. Without the help of David Bruck and the Center, co-counsel and I wouldn’t have known where to begin the impossible task assigned to us.”

Personal Injury Lawyers Representing Charleston & nearby areas of South Carolina

RESULTS

WE HAVE RECOVERED OVER $500 MILLION FOR CLIENTS IN THE LAST 10 YEARS, INCLUDING:
$2,750,000 in a product defect case, scissor lift malfunction.

What Our Clients Say About Us

I am very pleased with my experience

I have, and will continue to recommend The Steinberg Law Firm. They have worked very hard on my behalf.

It is hard to really put in writing how much Tom was there for me

He really did such an unbelievable job. Even when the settlement was made, he returned a text with a call to share in the joy over another medical event we were going through, that had a great outcome. Yes, they really do care.

I would highly recommend them

Enjoyed the fact that every time I called, someone called me back. It made me feel like my case mattered, and that I mattered. They answered all of my questions and concerns in a timely manner.

They will go the extra mile for you

David Pearlman and his staff did an exceptional job on my claim. Mr. Pearlman was honest, patient and steered me in the right direction. A’Riel was always nice and very helpful. I would recommend them to everyone.

I would never seek help from any other Firm!

The lawyers and their staff are very professional, caring about your situation! They are one of a kind!Get this Firm behind you and you will never be sorry!

It was a pleasure working with Steven Goldberg and his staff

They were courteous and professional. They maintained regular contact for status reports on my case and provided needed documentation on a timely basis. I would recommend this firm.