Is a Liability Waiver Enforceable in South Carolina? Gym, Sports, and Kids’ Activity Waivers
If you’ve ever joined a gym, rented a jet ski or other sporting equipment, visited a trampoline park, or signed yourself or a child up for a sports team, karate class, or summer camp, you have likely signed a liability waiver, sometimes called a release of liability or waiver form. These waivers are intended to protect the organization or rental facility from a lawsuit if you were to be injured while participating in their activities or using their equipment.
A waiver may be as short as a single sentence or may run to several pages. Regardless of its length, whether the waiver can be enforced depends on several factors, including what the waiver attempts to cover. How much of a waiver is enforceable often depends on the contents of the waiver itself and on what happened to you or your child.
If you signed a waiver and were later injured, don’t assume the waiver means you have no options. Talk to a South Carolina personal injury lawyer to learn about your options.
Common Clauses in South Carolina Gym, Sports, and Activity Liability Waivers
The most common clause in a liability waiver is an “exculpatory clause.” This language attempts to protect one party from a lawsuit by the other party, even if the first party was negligent.
For instance, an exculpatory clause in a sports team waiver might state that if the player who signs the waiver is injured, the player may not sue the sports team or anyone on its staff, even if the team or staff member’s negligence caused the player’s injuries.
Another common addition to activity waivers is an “assumption of risk agreement.” In an assumption of risk agreement, the person signing the waiver indicates that they know the activity involves certain risks, but they’re willing to participate anyway. For example, a waiver for a sports team might include an assumption-of-risk clause stating that the player is aware that concussions, bruises, and sprains are risks of playing the particular sport.
When Is a Liability Waiver Not Enforceable in South Carolina?
South Carolina courts have enforced exculpatory clauses in waivers, but a signed gym waiver or sports waiver is not automatically an enforceable waiver. In Pride v. Southern Bell Tel. & Tel. Co. (1964), the South Carolina Supreme Court stated that exculpatory clauses ‘tend to induce a want of care’ and are therefore not favored by the law and must be strictly construed against the party relying on them. As a result, courts view these clauses with skepticism.
Unless a waiver clearly states that both parties intended to protect one party against claims of negligence, South Carolina courts are not likely to find that a waiver actually does protect one party against a negligence claim by someone who was injured. The waiver must make it clear that the person who signs it is giving up their right to bring a negligence claim if they are injured, no matter how obvious it is that the other party’s negligence caused the injury.
- Waivers protecting one party from liability for negligence must be very clear and cannot be overly broad. In Fisher v. Stevens (2003), the South Carolina Court of Appeals held that if a waiver is so broad that it prevents one party from being held liable for anything at all, that waiver should be struck down as contrary to public policy.
- An assumption of risk clause allows a party to claim in court that they should not be held liable because the injured person “assumed the risk” of an activity. Assumption-of-risk clauses also have limits, however.
- A court is more likely to decide that an assumption of risk clause does not apply if the injury resulted from a risk that was hidden, known only to the negligent party, or was not foreseeable.
- For example, foreseeable risks of renting a jet ski include drowning or near-drowning, injuries caused by falling off the jet ski, and injuries caused by exposure to any electrical or mechanical parts of the jet ski. A jet ski with a hidden defect, however, poses a risk the renter can’t detect and may not discover until it is too late.
Likewise, a person who rents a jet ski but suffers injury by falling through a rotted board on the dock where the jet ski is moored may have a valid argument that the assumption of risk clause doesn’t cover their injuries. “The dock may be unsafe” may be a foreseeable risk of stepping onto a dock, but it is not a foreseeable risk of using a jet ski.
Kids’ Sports Waivers: Is a Waiver a Parent Signs for a Child Enforceable?
TK Challenges when the signer isn’t the participant. How can these be enforced or not? Back-to-school season is a common time for parents to sign waivers so their children can participate in sports. Each sports season brings its own fresh round of waivers.
Often, schools include a liability waiver in the seasonal paperwork. Like other activity waivers, the school sports liability waiver seeks to protect the school from legal liability if a student-athlete is injured.
- Children’s sports waivers raise unique questions. For many activity waivers, the signer is the participant. This person is typically an adult and often capable of identifying obvious or foreseeable risks.
- However, with school and after-school sports waivers, and with kids’ waivers for karate classes, gymnastics, and trampoline parks, the conditions may change. Often, the person who signs (the parent) is not the one who faces the risk of injury on the playing field or court (the child). A child playing sports may lack the life experience to spot risks that would be obvious or foreseeable to an adult. A parent can sign on behalf of the child, but even then, sports waivers are not always enforceable.
In this way, children’s sports waivers are similar to other types of activity waivers. Rules laid down by South Carolina courts for other types of waivers may also apply to sports waivers involving children. For example, waivers must be extremely clear and not too broad, or a court may find them unenforceable.
One example of a specific sports waiver is one that protects a school from liability if a student-athlete is injured during the normal course of a game or practice. This waiver may be enforceable if it focuses on the student’s participation in the normal course of the game as it is typically played or practiced. Such a waiver might not apply if, for example, the student trips on a piece of broken bus flooring and twists an ankle while boarding the bus to a game.
In addition, many courts recognize the general rule that contracts are not enforceable against minors. A court that holds to this rule may find that a waiver, being a type of contract, cannot be enforced against a minor. A school sports participant whose parent signed a waiver, then, may still be allowed to seek compensation for an injury.
Assumption-of-risk rules may apply in some school sports injury cases. However, for the assumption-of-risk rule to apply, the risk must be clear to the players and parents. For example, the risk of a concussion while playing football might be considered a clear risk. The risk cannot be hidden or known only to the school’s staff or coaches. For example, if a track runner twists her ankle when she steps on a piece of track that looks normal, the waiver may not apply, even if the maintenance staff knew it was broken.
Because the facts of an injury are often unique and not all waivers are identical, South Carolina courts consider sports waivers and injuries on a case-by-case basis. Courts generally require that the wording of such waivers be quite clear and precise.
What to Do If You Were Injured After Signing a Waiver in South Carolina
After an injury, you may wonder if the waiver you signed prevents you from bringing an injury claim. The company or person for whom you signed the waiver may even claim that you cannot bring a lawsuit or seek insurance coverage.
Studies show that waivers remain widely used. Liability waivers for activities are common even in states like South Carolina, where courts consider them on a case-by-case basis and do not enforce all waivers. Some organizations even continue to use a particular liability waiver after it has been declared unenforceable in court. The goal is to convince injured people that they don’t have a case – and shouldn’t bother trying to pursue one.
If your child is injured during an activity for which you signed a waiver, don’t assume the waiver prevents you from bringing an injury claim or filing for insurance coverage. Children’s sports and other waivers must contain clear language and are often limited in scope. Whether the waiver applies to your child’s situation must be determined based on the unique facts of your child’s injury.
Contact a Charleston Personal Injury Lawyer at Steinberg Law Firm Today
Whether they apply to an adult or a child, waivers are not automatically valid in all cases, and they do not automatically apply to every injury. South Carolina courts consider waivers on a case-by-case basis. To understand your options, talk to an experienced injury attorney.
If you’ve been seriously injured in an activity that involved a waiver, speak to an experienced South Carolina personal injury lawyer immediately. The attorneys at the Steinberg Law Firm serve injured people in Charleston, North Charleston, Hanahan, Goose Creek, Summerville, and communities across South Carolina. Our consultations are free, and there is no fee unless we collect financial compensation for you.
You May Also Like